Customer stories / CPG ยท Snacks

With XENA Intelligence

Testing a protein bar launch before the money was spent

A XENA Intelligence client was a few weeks from committing $410K to four new protein bars. XENA brought in Vantage to test the plan first.

44%of the launch budget saved
71%of stock sold in 90 days, up from 38% on the last launch

The situation

XENA pulls a brand's Amazon, Walmart, Shopify and TikTok Shop data into one place. A snack brand that had just signed on shared its next launch: four bars at $4.29, into every channel at once. The flavors came from an internal brainstorm and no consumer had seen them. The brand's last line extension sold 38% of its inventory in 90 days.

XENA's category data didn't support the plan. Most protein bars selling well online cost less than $4, and reviews kept mentioning digestion and texture problems.

What we did

  1. Concepts from XENA's data. About one in six negative reviews in the category mentioned sugar alcohols. We added two concepts built around that gap to the brand's four.
  2. Scored all six. Three moved to testing, one went back for rework and two were stopped before anyone paid for packaging.
  3. Modeled Consumer Responses. $3.79 looked workable in every channel. "No sugar alcohols" mattered more than grams of protein. People didn't want Cold Brew's caffeine in the afternoon.
  4. Human Responses. 600 recent protein bar buyers on Amazon, Walmart.com and TikTok Shop, fielded in five days.
  5. The recommendation. We presented it together with XENA. XENA now sends the launch sales data back to us, so we can see how the call played out.

What changed

Original planAfter the call
ProductsFour barsCrisp Bar in two flavors. Cold Brew retested later as a morning bar.
Price$4.29$3.79
ChannelsAll on day oneAmazon and TikTok Shop first. Walmart.com once sales picked up.
Budget$410K$230K, 44% less

The client's name and identifying details are withheld.

Next story: Picking the restaurant offer before the campaign money went out

Have a decision like this one?

Leave your work email and our team will get in touch.

Enter a valid work email.