Customer stories / CPG ยท Snacks
With XENA IntelligenceTesting a protein bar launch before the money was spent
A XENA Intelligence client was a few weeks from committing $410K to four new protein bars. XENA brought in Vantage to test the plan first.
The situation
XENA pulls a brand's Amazon, Walmart, Shopify and TikTok Shop data into one place. A snack brand that had just signed on shared its next launch: four bars at $4.29, into every channel at once. The flavors came from an internal brainstorm and no consumer had seen them. The brand's last line extension sold 38% of its inventory in 90 days.
XENA's category data didn't support the plan. Most protein bars selling well online cost less than $4, and reviews kept mentioning digestion and texture problems.
What we did
- Concepts from XENA's data. About one in six negative reviews in the category mentioned sugar alcohols. We added two concepts built around that gap to the brand's four.
- Scored all six. Three moved to testing, one went back for rework and two were stopped before anyone paid for packaging.
- Modeled Consumer Responses. $3.79 looked workable in every channel. "No sugar alcohols" mattered more than grams of protein. People didn't want Cold Brew's caffeine in the afternoon.
- Human Responses. 600 recent protein bar buyers on Amazon, Walmart.com and TikTok Shop, fielded in five days.
- The recommendation. We presented it together with XENA. XENA now sends the launch sales data back to us, so we can see how the call played out.
What changed
| Original plan | After the call | |
|---|---|---|
| Products | Four bars | Crisp Bar in two flavors. Cold Brew retested later as a morning bar. |
| Price | $4.29 | $3.79 |
| Channels | All on day one | Amazon and TikTok Shop first. Walmart.com once sales picked up. |
| Budget | $410K | $230K, 44% less |
The client's name and identifying details are withheld.
Next story: Picking the restaurant offer before the campaign money went out
Have a decision like this one?
Leave your work email and our team will get in touch.