Customer stories / Health and wellness ยท Cold therapy

Cold therapy manufacturer

Choosing the next product for an instant cold pack maker

A company that makes instant-activation cold packs had six directions on its roadmap. Vantage found the one worth building first, and what to prove before spending on tooling.

87/100score for the leading concept, the only one of six rated Strong Go
$15 to $30price of wearable cold products, against $0.75 to $1.50 for a commodity cold pack

The situation

The company's cold pack needs no freezer and cools within a controlled range. It sells into clinics, athletic training, physical therapy and retail. The roadmap had six possible next products, from hot packs to clinical kits. Its current pack competes with commodity packs that sell for about $0.75 to $1.50 each.

What we did

  1. Read what consumers say. Across Amazon reviews, competitor products and forums, the same complaints came up: cold packs don't stay cold long enough, and holding one against your body is a nuisance.
  2. Mapped the market. Cold and hot therapy is five markets, not one. The company's pack only competed in the cheapest, most crowded one.
  3. Scored six concepts. Each was rated on category health, consumer demand, competition, fit with what the company already makes, and how similar launches performed.
  4. Modeled Consumer Responses. Interest was modeled for each concept to rank them and find the strongest buyer segments.
  5. Planned Human Responses. A blind test of the top three concepts with about 575 consumers, clinicians and trainers, before any tooling spend.

How the six concepts scored

ConceptScoreCall
Wearable sleeve with a replaceable instant-cold insert87Strong Go
Post-surgery recovery kit82Go with changes
Large pack for training rooms and clinics80Go with changes
Small travel pack79Go with changes
Lower-impact version of the current pack70Go with changes
Instant heat pack67Conditional

The recommendation

Build a cooling system, not six separate pouches: one standard insert that snaps into sleeves for different body parts. Wearable cold products already sell at a premium because they're hands-free, and the company's chemistry removes the freezer from the picture.

Before any tooling spend, lab-confirm how long the insert stays cold, then test the top three concepts blind with real consumers. Hold the heat pack and the lower-impact pack until the wearable is validated.

The client's name and product names are withheld.

Next story: Turning an affordable nutrition idea into something a consumer could react to

Have a decision like this one?

Leave your work email and our team will get in touch.

Enter a valid work email.